A website came under fire Tuesday, accused of stealing the Sun Devils trademark owned by Arizona State University. The adult entertainment website is SunDevilAngels.com.
ASU is going head to head with the creator of Sun Devil Angels in hopes that either the name will change or the site will go down altogether. They've asked for an arbitration hearing where both sides can duke it out. And a trademark attorney we spoke with says they may have a good case.
"You have extremes here, I mean on one hand, you have ASU which is like motherhood and apple pie, and the other hand you have not just any business, you have a porn site," said Donald Hudspeth. He is a business attorney, and while he isn't connected with this case, he has plenty of experience with trademark battles.
"Who had the name first? Is it being used for legitimate purpose?" Hudspeth said of the questions that will likely be asked.
He said the creator of adult website SunDevilAngels.com should've seen this coming after his trademark application was denied in 2008 because the name could cause confusion with ASU's trademark, Sun Devils.
"The general principle of law is that the trade name, trademark, trumps domain name," Hudspeth said.
The trademark application was filed by Raymond Coates, who listed an address in Mesa as the place of his business. That's where we ran into some of his family friends. They tell us Coates started the site because of his passionate for photography. They claim he wasn't trying to taint the image of Arizona State University; he just chose the name because the site features local women.
Back in 2010, Coates also registered the name Millennium Vision Productions, saying the business was "photography entertainment." Though his family friends claim Coates no longer lives in Arizona, SunDevilAngels.com is still active.
Hudspeth said this could be tied up in court for years if either side appeals the arbitration's judgment.
"You protect your trademark because that's your identity, that's your brand, that's everything," he said.
On Tuesday the Twitter page for Sun Devil Angels posted a link to a story discussing the pending legal battle, asking, "Wat (sic) do you guys think?" We reached out to Coates via his family friends and email, but have not heard back. We also requested an interview with ASU but they would only confirm the dispute.
Copyright 2013 CBS 5 (KPHO Broadcasting Corporation). All rights reserved.
Thursday, May 23 2013 12:39 PM EDT2013-05-23 16:39:28 GMT
Dan Marco's son was murdered in 2010. (Source: CBS 5 News)
Only people who have lost a close loved one can understand the pain of Travis Alexander's family"My heart goes out to them, because I understand," says Dan Marco, who's son Zachary was murdered in 2010.ZacharyMore >
Only people who have lost a close loved one can understand the pain of Travis Alexander's family.More >
Friday, May 24 2013 10:40 PM EDT2013-05-25 02:40:59 GMT
Closed iBeach Tan location in Gilbert.
Tracy Grogitsky purchased two memberships to the iBeach Tan salon in Gilbert just a few weeks ago. She said one was for a gift for her friends. Thursday, she went to the location to tan. "I thought, 'Oh,More >
Two local tanning salons closed without notice, and customers say they're not getting any refunds. More >
Friday, May 24 2013 12:29 PM EDT2013-05-24 16:29:51 GMT
Every week, CBS 5 News is sent a list of restaurants that have been recently inspected by Maricopa County's Environmental Services Department. CBS 5 News selects five restaurants with some of the highestMore >
Every week, CBS 5 News is sent a list of restaurants that have been recently inspected by Maricopa County's Environmental Services Department.More >
Friday, May 24 2013 4:19 PM EDT2013-05-24 20:19:28 GMT
The Young and the Restless is airing a special tribute episode to the late Jeanne Cooper on Tuesday, May 28 at 11 a.m. MST. Cast members and friends of Cooper recently gathered on set to shoot a celebrationMore >
The Young and the Restless is airing a special tribute episode to the late Jeanne Cooper on Tuesday, May 28 at 11 a.m. MST.More >
Friday, May 24 2013 8:35 PM EDT2013-05-25 00:35:27 GMT
(Source: CBS 5 News)
The Jodi Arias jury couldn't decide whether to sentence the convicted killer to death, or give her life in prison. Now the question is... what happens next? Former Superior Court Judge David Cole saidMore >
The Jodi Arias jury couldn't decide whether to sentence the convicted killer to death, or give her life in prison. Now the question is ... what happens next? More >
The valley is preparing to say its final goodbyes to a fallen Phoenix police officer. Visitation was held Friday night for Officer Daryl Raetz - with a steady stream of his family, friends and colleagues.More >
Visitation was held Friday night for Officer Daryl Raetz - with a steady stream of his family, friends and colleagues - ahead of Saturday's funeral.More >