When the justices of the United States Supreme Court allowed Arizona to move forward with the portion of a tough new immigration law that allows police to demand proof of a suspect's citizenship, they did so with some caution.
That caution is taking center stage as a class action civil rights lawsuit tests whether Sheriff Joe Arpaio's controversial crime sweeps violate the constitutional rights of people who look "Mexican." The trial began at 8:30 a.m. Thursday in federal court in Phoenix.
It was standing room only. No cameras were allowed and there's no jury, just a group of attorneys, witnesses and a judge. Arpaio was not present at Thursday morning's proceedings.
The ACLU represents the plaintiffs, a group of citizens and legal residents who claim they were detained, targeted and/or harassed because of the way they look or their ethnic background.
The ACLU is arguing that the sheriff's office set up a dragnet for illegal immigrants, failed to follow established guidelines for anti-discriminatory policing and that citizens and legal residents got caught in the middle.
The defense Thursday morning was grilling an expert who said studies show 80 percent of traffic stops are because of race. Dr. Ralph Taylor, professor of criminal justice at Temple University, testified if an incident took place during the time a saturation patrol was in effect, there was a high likelihood that the name checked would be Hispanic.
Tim Casey, who represents the defense, maintained the plaintiffs have no evidence that race does not play a factor in any of their traffic stops. Race and ethnicity had nothing to do with any stops of any individuals, he said. Casey added there has never been a saturation patrol that has not been based on criminal activity.
"Facts are facts, statistics are statistics and they can be interpreted," said Maricopa County Supervisor Mary Rose Wilcox. "But I thought they were very telling."
Toward the end of the day, two men who claimed they were racially profiled took the stand. One said during a crime sweep in Mesa, he was stopped and the first thing the deputy asked was if he spoke English.
The other witness said he was stopped along with five other drivers for passing a road closed signed. But he was the only one ticketed. He is Hispanic. The four others were reportedly white.
It is expected that during the course of the trial several more of those people who claimed they were victims of racial profiling will take the stand.
Arpaio is expected to testify on Tuesday.
Deputies will be called to testify on what they've seen and been instructed to do when it comes to race.
Ultimately, this case will be one step toward answering the Supreme Court's last remaining question about SB 1070. That is, whether local police can enforce immigration law without violating the civil rights of citizens.
The case is called Melendres v. Arpaio. You can find a link to the ACLU's web page on the case here.
Copyright 2012 CBS 5 (Meredith Corporation). All rights reserved.
Wednesday, June 19 2013 11:01 AM EDT2013-06-19 15:01:14 GMT
Cell phone records show the young woman who vanished just blocks away from her Tempe apartment over the weekend made a phone call before she disappeared. Adrienne Salinas, 19, hasn't been seen or heardMore >
Cell phone records show the young woman who vanished just blocks away from her Tempe apartment over the weekend made a phone call before she disappeared.More >
Wednesday, June 19 2013 3:36 PM EDT2013-06-19 19:36:55 GMT
Gun threat at Arizona Mills Mall
A gun threat forced the evacuation of Arizona Mills Mall Tuesday night. A caller told 911 that someone was pointing a gun at theater-goers while they were watching a movie. The scene is unfolding andMore >
A caller told 911 that someone pointed a gun at theater-goers while they were watching the new 'Superman' movie.More >
Wednesday, June 19 2013 4:58 PM EDT2013-06-19 20:58:02 GMT
The man suspected of kidnapping three women and holding them captive for years inside his west side is due in court this morning. Ariel Castro will go before Judge Michael Russo at 8:30 a.m. on nearlyMore >
With his head hanging down, suspected kidnapper Ariel Castro went before a judge on Wednesday morning.
Castro refused to make eye contact with anyone, but did answer the judge when questioned. He provided a simple answer of 'yes' when asked normal questions about the proceedings. More >
Friday, May 31 2013 8:01 PM EDT2013-06-01 00:01:34 GMT
A bus driver loses his job over a Facebook post. Here's hold it unfolded. The last week of school in Haralson County, a student told driver Johnny Cook he was hungry, that didn't get to eat lunch at HaralsonMore >
A bus driver recently lost his job over a Facebook post. More >
Wednesday, June 19 2013 1:40 PM EDT2013-06-19 17:40:44 GMT
Jesus Cabrera Molina (Source: CBS 5 News)
A judge has denied bond for man believed involved in the hit-and-run death of a Phoenix police officer.Police say 24-year-old Jesus Cabrera Molina is being held on suspicion of manslaughter and leavingMore >
Maricopa County court officials said Jesus Cabrera Molina, 24, pleaded not guilty to charges of manslaughter and leaving the scene of the crash in the hit-and-run death of a Phoenix police officer.More >