[Editor's note: The Federation for American Immigration Reform (FAIR) contacted CBS 5 News to say FAIR does not fund the Center for Immigration Studies (CIS), as was originally reported in the following story. In fact, FAIR does not currently fund CIS. According to the Southern Poverty Law Center, CIS originally started as a program run by FAIR and shares many of the same donors and fund raisers.]
When you look at the Supreme Court's decision there's a statistic that really sticks out. It states illegal immigrants are responsible for 21.8 percent of all felonies in Maricopa County.
"Off the top of my head it sounds like it's impossible," said Bill Straus, with the Anti-Defamation League.
The group that provided that information to the Court is the Center for Immigration Studies.
CBS 5 News found their original report and saw a big problem.
The study said illegal immigrants make up 21.8 percent of felonies, inmates, arrests or bookings, not just felonies.
How did that so-called fact make its way into the Supreme Court's decision?
"You can call that sloppy. I think that's a good term," said ASU law professor Paul Bender.
Bender said the Court can use any information from any source it wants in its opinions.
"Now they should be careful when they do that and only use things that are accurate. There's no excuse for having an opinion say something that's different from the studies because somebody, a law clerk, can read the studies and just make sure it's right. And should," Bender said.
Setting aside the numbers issue, CBS 5 News took a look at where that data comes from.
The Center for Immigration Studies was founded by FAIR.
"The Federation of American Immigration Reform and that's an organization the ADL is well aware of," Straus said.
Straus said one word describes FAIR.
"No question about it, they are an extremist group," he said.
Straus said knowing FAIR founded the group that provided those numbers to the Supreme Court seems a little fishy.
"That's not only sad but it's very scary because we see the information coming out of FAIR and they're anything but objective," he said.
Bender said those misleading numbers didn't shape the Court's decision, but that the justices need to be very careful, not only about fact checking, but also checking where those facts come from.
Copyright 2012 KPHO(Meredith Corporation). All rights reserved.
Tuesday, December 10 2013 8:17 PM EST2013-12-11 01:17:03 GMT
Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio
Sheriff Joe Arpaio said Tuesday he will house about 150 military veteran inmates under one roof in a segregated section of the Towers Jail facility. The new military veterans housing unit will featureMore >
"They fight for us overseas, so, we must fight for them here," Sheriff Joe Arpaio said. "When their duty is done, ours has just begun."More >
Wednesday, December 11 2013 12:55 AM EST2013-12-11 05:55:28 GMT
Claudia Ann Lucero, Alex Madrid
Mesa police have announced they've made an arrest in the death of a 14-year-old girl whose body was found in a trash container early Friday morning. Officers said they took the victims' mother's ex-boyfriendMore >
Alex Madrid, 31, of Mesa, a convicted felon and the boyfriend of the victim's mother, was taken into custody in connection with the death of 14-year-old Claudia Ann Lucero, who was strangled and sexually assaulted, police said.More >
Tuesday, December 10 2013 11:54 PM EST2013-12-11 04:54:32 GMT
(RNN) - Gil Brandt of NFL.com and ESPN radio host Paul Finebaum are reporting that Alabama's Nick Saban is in contract negotiations with the university for a contract extension that would pay him $7 millionMore >
Reports are swirling that Alabama football coach Nick Saban has a contract extension on his desk from Alabama. Meanwhile, conflicting reports coming from Texas say that coach Mack Brown may be on his way out this week. More >
Tuesday, December 10 2013 11:06 PM EST2013-12-11 04:06:37 GMT
Meteor sighted in southern Arizona
A meteor was observed streaking across the sky in southern Arizona shortly after 7 p.m., CBS 5 viewers reported. Reports of a #meteor across southern Arizona shortly after 7pm. Many more reports outMore >
There were more sightings in the Tucson area than Phoenix, although some viewers reported seeing it in the sky over the southeast Valley.More >
Tuesday, December 10 2013 6:54 PM EST2013-12-10 23:54:30 GMT
The F-35B was the star of the show at Luke Air Force Base Tuesday morning. "I heard a rumor it was going to be here for the Singapore guys to check it out, so I wanted to see it in action and I came out,More >
F-35B aircraft spotted at Luke Air Force Base Tuesday morning.More >
Tuesday, December 10 2013 11:24 PM EST2013-12-11 04:24:49 GMT
CBS 5 News
This time of year if you haven't come down with a cold consider yourself lucky. "Most of them come from your hands. You touch surfaces, you scratch your nose, the virus gets in," said Dr. Don BucklinMore >
This time of year if you haven't come down with a cold consider yourself lucky. More >
Tuesday, December 10 2013 10:59 PM EST2013-12-11 03:59:12 GMT
Valley businessman Fred Knadler remains in jail, accused of hiring someone to kill his wife - twice. Phoenix police have compiled an abundance of evidence, which includes an audio recording of KnadlerMore >
Valley businessman Fred Knadler remains in jail, accused of hiring someone to kill his wife - twice. More >