Homepage / Phoenix News
E-Mail News Alerts
Get breaking news and daily headlines.
Browse all e-mail newsletters

| More


Woman, 97, Battles Voter ID Law

POSTED: 8:01 pm MST June 9, 2008
UPDATED: 10:26 am MST June 10, 2008

A 97-year-old Surprise woman who has voted in the past 19 presidential elections said she finds herself a casualty in the voter ID battle.

READ: Legal Documents In Arizona's Voter ID Case

Shirley Preiss cannot register in Arizona for the November elections without proof of citizenship.

"I'm a legal American," Preiss said. "I'm born here. Born and raised in America."

The Arizona law was approved by voters in 2004 as Proposition 200 on that year’s general election ballot. It requires voters to produce specified types of identification when casting ballots at polling places and to provide proof of citizenship when registering to vote either for the first time or in a different county.

Preiss was born in 1910 in Clinton, Ky., before birth certificates were issued. She said she no longer has a driver's license and never had a passport.

"You can see my mother's not a national threat," said her son Nathan Nemnich. "Been voting since 1932." Nemnich produced the files documenting his attempts to get her registered.

"A delayed birth certificate," he said. "You have to have witnesses. Everybody's dead."

When the family tried to get school records from Tennessee, they found out the school no longer exists.

"We're talking about something that is so precious, that right to vote, "said Linda Brown of the Arizona Advocacy Network. "How many hurdles are OK to jump through? How many barriers are we going to accept?"

State Rep. Russell Pearce spearheaded the law and said it protects the integrity of the voting system.

"To get a movie, you have to prove who you are," Pearce said. "To go rent a car, you have to prove who you are. That's part of life."

Preiss said for someone who once lived in a time when women could not vote, the law is a step backwards. The former school teacher said she has voted in every presidential election since 1932.

Nemnich said his next step is to call the governor's office for help.

Experts said it's hard to say how many other people are in the same situation as Preiss. But the Arizona Advocacy Network said almost 40,000 voter registration forms have been rejected since the state's voter ID law went into effect.

SLIDESHOW: Web Site Names Top 10 'Hells On Earth' SLIDESHOW: Get The Skinny On Celebrity Weight SLIDESHOW: 60s And 70s Rockers Then And Now SLIDESHOW: FHM's 2008 World's Sexiest Women SLIDESHOW: Reader-Submitted Tattoo Photos SLIDESHOW: Red-Hot Redheaded Celebrity Women SLIDESHOW: Here Are 10 Crazy Excuses For Being Late

  • ELSEWHERE ON KPHO.COM: Court records unsealed Monday afternoon show the man accused of being Mesa's serial predator admitted to sexually assaulting two women and leaving another for dead. CLICK HERE for details.
  • MORE SLIDESHOWS: From the bizarre to the tragic to late-breaking news, visit the KPHO.com slideshow section and click away! CLICK HERE for images.

  • Links We Like
    Sponsored Content
    Having trouble selling your home? These tips will make your property a hot commodity. More

    Sitting at a desk all day is a one way ticket to poor fitness. Find out how you can work to stay in shape regardless of your work situation. More

    Feeling bloated or uncomfortable after eating? Try these five recipes and find out why they are so good for digestion. More

    You think your state has some strange laws? Think again. Here are five states with some of the strangest. More

    Sponsored Links

    Auto Reviews & Tips

    The vehicles are selected for best protecting motorists in front, side and rear crash tests based on Institute evaluations during the year. More